Grey Market Kaypros
Microcomputer vendor Kaypro Corp., Solano Beach, CA, recently had its wrists slapped by the California attorney general's office for allegedly threatening to terminate contracts with some of its authorized dealers caught discounting prices below suggested retail levels and selling to unauthorized outlets.
Without trial or admission of guilt, Kaypro agreed to pay the state $19,500 in civil penalties and lawyers' fees and promised to refrain from any violation of California's antitrust laws.
It's common practice for micro hardware and software vendors to terminate contracts with authorized dealers that sell products to third parties-the gray market-which resell products for reduced prices.
Some see the ruling as a minor victory for the gray market and for users seeking lower prices. However, computer-law expert L.J. Kutten, St. Louis, claims the ruling will only make "vendors more circumspect in terminating dealers in the future ."
Vendors, Kutten explains, can set any reasonable business provisions they want in their dealer contracts. For instance, he says, vendors are allowed to terminate agreements with dealers for "legitimate business reasons," such as a change of market strategy. But vendors may not enter into a "conspiracy" to enforce termination provisions in their contracts. If a dealer complains to a vendor about the discounting practices of another dealer, leading to the latter's termination, that's conspiracy to fix prices. Kaypro could have avoided the penalty by terminating contracts under the guise of a new distribution strategy, Kutten says, "but they were clumsy."
The injunction against Kaypro stipulates that the manufacturer may not monitor the pricing of its dealers, nor may it terminate or threaten to terminate contracts with authorized dealers on the basis of pricing. Kaypro would not comment on the case.
(Computer Decisions, Auguat 27, 1985)